RSH_100w.gif (2252 bytes)

RSH > Documents > Tokyo 1999 > Thomas D. Luckey 1999
previous.jpg (4111 bytes)

PROGRAM

Radiation Health Effects: Applying Data to Standards

Evidence of a Requirement for Radiation

By Thomas D. Luckey

Loveland, Colorado

Evidence of a requirement for ionizing radiation completes the dose-response curve for this ubiquitous agent (Fig. 1). LOW DOSE is any dose between TWO THRESHOLDS: one at ambient levels, A, and the threshold of harm, ZEP. The radiation deficiency syndrome includes: DECREASED growth rate, neuromuscular development, mental acuity, reproduction immune competence and mean lifespan; INCREASED sterility, infections, neonatal deaths and mortality rates for respiratory diseases, cardiovascular disease and cancer.

A radiation deficiency was obtained by maintaining non-vertebrates in laboratories with <10% of ambient levels of ionizing radiation. The results (Table) consistently show ionizing radiation is essential for non-vertebrates. Comparable mammalian research is needed.

Increased reproduction and mean lifespan of rats fed uranium dust was the basis for the first limits on radiation set by the Health Physics Society. Brown found the 12th

Figure 1

ORGANISM

EFFECT

WEEKS

%*

AUTHOR, YEAR

ALGA

VIABILITY

10+

0

EUGASTER, 1954

ALGA

VIABILITY

1

72

PLANEL, 1979

BARLEY SEED

VIABILITY

10+

9

EUGASTER, 1954

PARAMECIA**

GROWTH

1

5

LUCKEY, 1978

PARAMECIA**

GROWTH

1

41

PLANEL, 1979

PARAMECIUM

GROWTH

1/2

56

LUCKEY, 1986

SHRIMP EGGS

VIABILITY

10+

0

EUGASTER, 1954

generation of rats continuously exposed to 2 cGy/d gamma rays had better reproduction than controls: 117 % more litters, 152% increased litter size, 147% more weaned young and 172% increased total weight of litters. Similar experiments were continued for 12-82 generations. Japanese babies from parents who were exposed to atomic bombs with <20 cGy showed 30% fewer molecular mutations, 33% fewer chromosomal aberrations and fewer

phenotypic abnormalities than controls. Clearly, low dose irradiation enhances reproduction.

Total cancer mortality in 140,000 nuclear workers exposed to average lifetime exposures of 5.5 cSv was only 51% that of 136,000 carefully selected unexposed workers from the same plants. This result has been amply confirmed with both human and animal populations exposed to low levels of ionizing radiation. Predictably, safe radiation supplementation would prevent almost half of our premature cancer deaths. The nuclear worker data suggest 5 cSv/y is safe.

Figure 2

The statistically significant benefit of low dose radiation in lifespan (Fig. 2) was denied by those who used median rather than mean or average values. However, this benefit has been confirmed in more than 20 reports with experimental animals. Humans show comparable results. Those Japanese exposed to low dose irradiation from atom bombs have a longer average lifespan than controls. Increased immunity decreases mortality rates from cancer and cardiovascular and respiratory diseases. This increases the average lifespan.

The conclusion: safe supplementation of ionizing radiation would elicit a new plateau of health.

 

 

The Seventh International Conference on Nuclear Engineering
Special Symposium

April 21, 1999
Concorde Ball Room, Keio Plaza inter-Continental Tokyo


RSH > Documents > Tokyo 1999 > Thomas D. Luckey 1999
previous.jpg (4111 bytes)

For more information please contact the RSH President Jim Muckerheide

For website problems please contact the Webmaster
 

Google Scholar

06/13/06